Three teams of directors stage Richard Wagner's "Valkyrie" at the Stuttgart State Opera. With amazing results.
The small rat is very excited. She whizzes along a train track, past ruins, through destroyed houses, past tubes of paint and the remains of other things needed to create art. The rat is looking for shelter, a few of its own kind are chasing it, it moves exactly to the rhythm of the music, driven by the roaring overture. You see the rats large on a screen, that looks like a hole in a wall or, depending on the lighting, like the crown of the ash tree, whose trunk stands here quite lost on center stage. But you can also see them in real life, puppets on threads moved by people, scurrying across the stage.
The Stuttgart State Opera is once again using an idea that caused a sensation more than 20 years ago. At the time, artistic director Klaus Zehelein commissioned four different artistic teams to stage the four parts of Richard Wagner’s “Ring of the Nibelung”. His successor Viktor Schoner is now repeating the process and intensifying it. Not only is each part of the “Ring” created by a different director, in “Valkyrie” there is a different artistic team for each of the three acts. The opera starts with the first act of Dutch theater company Hotel Modern, which consists of Pauline Kalker, Arlène Hoornweg and Herman Helle, and what they create is quite sensational. As is this whole “Valkyrie”: the contradiction of the directors’ concepts seen here is an exciting undertaking.
Hotel Modern were guests at the Salzburg Festival in 2007, where they presented their deeply moving theatre production “Kamp”. They recreated a day in the Auschwitz concentration camp, without text, just with many small figures who died, suffered, went to the gas chambers in a model of the death camp. The audience saw a film that referred to the canon of images of horror and at the same time they saw how it was made: the stage model and the figurines in it were filmed live. As a requiem for the victims, it was a heartrending performance.
Hotel Modern now uses this concept in the first act of the “Valkyrie”, not their first opera work, but it is probably their most fascinating one. At both sides of the stage the audience sees large tables with many small models for the live filming. Centre stage stands a barren ash tree. No humans in their ‘live animation’, only the rats that are on the run. The world around them is devastated, like at the end of a war, the houses only skeletons, wrecked tanks in an apocalyptic landscape. The rats are looking for protection that doesn’t exist. At present one can’t help but seeing a commentary on world events, but it’s all written by Wagner. Hunding and Siegmund were in a clan war, Sieglinde has experienced violence in her past. Three wounded people meet each other here, a bit of rosemary timidly greens when the blissful moon rises, northern lights scurry across an ice surface.
In Act 1, the three soloists enter with rat masks, which they quickly take off. Dressed in what appears to be randomly chosen from the clothing rack, they powerfully fill the theatre with their voices. As Siegmund, Michael König relies on an immense, baritonal foundation, and in the second act bright colors are added to his voice. Goran Jurić as Hunding is an elemental force, Simone Schneider highly dramatic, powerful, wild. The three singers hardly act, some facial expressions, a few statuesque gestures, that’s all. But what could be observed as a failure in directing becomes a fascinating trialogue between the characters, the images and the music. One hears the war from the orchestra pit, where Cornelius Meister conducts with precise craftsmanship; real theater music, very positivistic, also quite loud, but one can hear the soloists surprisingly well. The three singers stand like symbols in a destroyed world in which nothing ever again will be whole.
Notung, the sword, descends from above as a huge and imminent warning, drawn down by cords. Violence hovers in and above the scene. In an interview in the program book, Hotel Modern says: “The question of how relevant the war is, is a question of kilometers, not a question of time.”
Wagner’s “Ring” is a narrative about the world, but with the world no longer consistent, why should an opera performance be? The great advantage of dividing the stage direction into three parts is that each team can concentrate on one act and treat it like a complete piece. So you can go further aesthetically than if you are obliged to keep the whole narrative in mind. While Hotel Modern still deal sharply with the content and the production of theatre, the subsequent acts are above all aesthetic settings, and exceptionally dense as well.
Urs Schönebaum worked with Robert Wilson for a long time, and his second act is in no way inferior to Wilson’s light-space constellations in terms of pictorial perfection. Schönebaum does the stage direction, the scenography and the light design – and first sheds light on family issues. One sees a piece of driftwood, probably from the ash tree. Wotan plays with his children Siegmund and Sieglinde and Brunhilde appears as a dear daughter. The first “Hojotoho” is playful irony. But then Wotan’s wife Fricka, the fearless Annika Schlicht, bullies him and also ensnares him erotically until he collapses as a powerless husband.
After these scenes, Schönebaum plays ironically with everything martial: gloomy towers are pushed on stage, fog wafts around, Brunhilde returns with dark henchmen, torches flicker. But the power has long been hollow and in the end Wotan murders Siegmund in a wild slaughter, like a mad man who has no way out.
The contrast with the third act can hardly be more amazing. Cheerful Valkyries, colorfully dressed, frolic around on a stage full of colorful waves that are constantly in motion. A friendly color bath. Ulla von Brandenburg, visual artist and professor in Karlsruhe, loves colors and fabrics. On the day of the “Valkyrie” premiere, an exhibition opened in the Staatsgalerie next door, celebrating Oskar Schlemmer’s Triadic Ballet, which premiered 100 years ago in Stuttgart. Brandenburg has designed one of the museum’s rooms, a yellow cocoon with a few utensils, Valkyrie spears and pick-up sticks.
Something similar is seen on stage in the third act, and even if Brandenburg’s beautiful play of colors could hardly be endured for a whole “Valkyrie”, it nevertheless unmistakably steers towards the decisive moment of the entire opera: Wotan’s farewell to his beloved Brunhilde. This is staged so humanly true, so touching, so sad. Brian Mulligan as Wotan and Okka von der Damerau as Brunhilde, both making their role debuts here, are by no means the greatest vocalists, but they have something else at their disposal. Something rare in these roles: a tender, wondrous poetry that goes directly to the heart. Cornelius Meister does not make it easy for them, his orchestra is too loud and too slow, which is particularly difficult for Mulligan’s Wotan. But still: At the end of the whole “Valkyrie” it’s no longer about gods and worlds, but about people, real people. That’s wonderful, and rounds off an experiment that, in all its disparity, works out fascinatingly well.
And: When does one ever get to see three opera productions in one evening?
11-04-2022
